Gotham Steel Cookware Review

I firmly believe that food tastes better when it’s cooked in a beautiful, sturdy pan. It’s no wonder that many people are eyeing pots and pans from Gotham Steel. 

Before you buy, I’m sure you want to know if these products are worth the hype. Are they safe to use? Are they easy to cook with, and better yet, easy to clean?

I decided to find out by giving these pots and pans a try. Read my Gotham Steel cookware review to learn about this brand’s durability, non-stick performance, and handling safety.

Product Overview

We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
10/03/2022 12:20 am GMT

Gotham Steel cookware comes in all shapes and sizes, each crafted from solid aluminum with a non-stick ceramic surface. The company makes everything from spatulas to baking sheets, but their pots and pans are the stars of the show.

Gotham prides itself on using non-toxic materials, which is pretty essential for anything your food touches. The products are excellent for casual cooks who want dependable, high-quality kitchen tools that last for many years. 


  • Non-toxic materials
  • Dishwasher and oven-safe
  • Lightweight and easy to clean


  • Non-stick coating wears down over time
  • Hot handles on some pots


To get a sense of how well these pots and pans work, let’s dive into the details of Gotham’s products. The last thing you want is a skillet that scratches easily or a dutch oven that needs endless scrubbing to remove stubborn grime.

With each purchase, Gotham Steel guarantees the following features:

  • Ovenproof up to 500 degrees
  • Scratch-resistant
  • Flame resistant
  • Super non-stick surface
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Easy clean
  • Lifetime warranty


Like I mentioned, Gotham products are surprisingly light for their metal build. I picked up a frying pan first and found it very easy to lift and toss food on the burner.

I was pleasantly surprised when I cooked an egg on the pan’s non-stick surface. It was easy to scrape off my egg with the Gotham spatula as soon as it finished cooking. Later, I tossed the pan into the sink and found it easy to scrub clean.


Gotham cookware is undoubtedly durable, and it doesn’t hurt that these pans have a lifetime warranty either way. Ultimately, every non-stick pan is going to wear down with enough use, so it’s good to know you can get a replacement as the coating begins to fade.

Handling Safety

Next, let’s take a look at the safety of these items. Cookware needs to come with handles that don’t absorb stovetop heat and burn your hands. I found that the frying pan stayed incredibly cool with its long handle away from the burner.

The pasta pot was more challenging to handle without potholders, but this is relatively common with large stovetop items that don’t have an extended handle.

I found that even when I loaded up some of the cookware with heavy contents, like pasta in water or thick soup, the handles stayed firmly in place with no bending or rattling.

Cooking Evenness

Of course, a review won’t be complete without judging Gotham Steel cookware’s actual cooking ability. After making a fried egg, a stack of pancakes, a sheet of cookies, and a pot of Linguine, I was pleased with the results. 

The ceramic surface on the Gotham pans did an excellent job of spreading heat from the burner across the entire cooking area. I noticed my pancakes browning evenly from edge to edge without over-crisping.

Social Proof

Don’t just take it from me. I scoured the internet for what other customers had to say about Gotham Steel cookware. Here are a few of the results:


Of course, Gotham Steel isn’t the only cookware manufacturer making sturdy kitchen essentials. If you’re looking for other, similar options, here are my top choices:


These non-toxic, non-stick pans are a favorite among home chefs. Like Gotham Steel, Caraway uses a clean ceramic finish in elegant colorways. I especially love how easy it is to store a Caraway set, as the pots and pans fit together in neat stacks for maximum storage potential. 

They do come at a slightly steeper price point, but this company also offers deals if you buy your cookware as a set. Check out Caraway as a durable, dependable alternative.


This cookware brand stands out from other options because it’s made of pure ceramic. If you’re a fan of low and slow cooking methods, in the oven or on the stovetop, you can trust that Xtrema locks in tons of heat with its non-toxic materials. 

Xtrema may be the safest pan you’ve ever cooked in, with an FDA-approved design free of artificial non-stick surface chemicals. However, the warranty only lasts for ten years as opposed to Gotham Steel’s lifetime guarantee. And with a fully ceramic pot, you might need a little more shattering insurance. 

Red Copper

We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
10/02/2022 10:01 am GMT

Last but not least, Red Copper is perhaps the most similar line of cookware to Gotham Steel. Both companies use ceramic and aluminum to craft durable, non-stick options. You’ll see some variety in the sizing, with Red Copper using slightly different dimensions that may not be ideal for some ultra-specific baking recipes.

Red Copper also has a slightly flatter heating pad on its frying pans because there is no logo on the bottom of the vessel. If you’re hunting for the flattest pancake cooker, this might be the best alternative for you.


Overall, I’m impressed with Gotham Steel cookware. These kitchen pieces are reliable staples that make an excellent upgrade to your old, scratched-up pots and pans. They come with an elegant finish and a lifetime guarantee.

I know I can’t wait for my next big cooking project when I can slide my dinner off the non-stick coating and let my dishwasher handle the cleanup. 

Whether you’re eyeing the grill pan or the crisper tray, the luxury of using a quality piece of cookware is well worth it.

Things to Consider Before Buying Gotham Steel Cookware

The last thing you want to worry about is what’s seeping into your food while it’s cooking in the pot. It’s essential to use cookware that is safe, and even better if it’s easy to use and clean. 

Before you buy, it’s helpful to think about what kind of cook you are. If you do a range of cooking and baking projects each week, it may be time to invest in a full set of Gotham Steel cookware.

If you’re a minimalist who only fries up eggs at home, perhaps you only need a skillet. Still, you should consider the size of your omelets, the sink you’ll wash your pans in, and whether you’ll cook on a gas range or an induction cooker.

All in all, going with Gotham Steel Cookware for your cookware of choice is still a solid option.

Share This Post!

Related Posts

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.